PARC Projects

Biodiversity protection
Improving environmental risk assessments for plant protection products
Environment
NGRA
Risk assessment
Time span
-
Potential impacts
  • Supporting risk assessors at the EU and member state levels by providing improved tools for evaluating plant protection products during the authorisation process.
  • Enhancing the transition to a systems-based Environmental Risk Assessment process by improving the reusability of data generated during environmental risk assessments.
  • Streamline the Environmental Risk Assessment process for plant protection products by identifying opportunities to simplify assessments and allocate resources more efficiently.
Partners involved
RPTU (DE)
ANSES (FR)
SLU (SE)
EAWAG (CH)
EFSA (IT)
FOEN (CH)
KEMI (SE)
IEP-NRI (PL)
NIVA (NO)
UBA (DE)
UFZ (DE)
ULUND (SE)
UOB (GB)
UOS (DE)
Contacts
Ralf Schulz (RPTU)
r.schulz [at] rptu.de
Larissa Herrmann (RPTU)
l.herrmann [at] rptu.de
Media
Key messages
  • The scientific basis of the pesticide environmental risk assessment needs to be strengthened, and the regulatory complexity needs to be bechmarked;
  • The validation status of exposure models in the environmental risk assessment of pesticides needs to be improved;
  • Measured and predicted environmental pesticide concentrations have to be contextualized to assess the real exposure situation;
  • The overall aim is the optimization of complexity within the regulatory exposure assessment of pesticides to ensure protectiveness.
Overview

This project is part of PARC Activity “Risk assessment to support and promote efficient overall protection of biodiversity”, which focuses on enhancing environmental risk assessment (ERA) methods. The aim of this project is to investigate the potential for simplifying and improving the predictions in the exposure assessment of the authorization process for plant protection products (PPP, commonly known as pesticides) under Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009. The current process is intricate and resource-intensive, prompting to optimize the space between necessary model complexity to achieve a protective predictive capacity and regulatory feasibility. The focus is on the ERA of pesticides with the long-term aim to expand the scope to support chemical ERA in general.

During Y 1-3, this project performed an extensive “reality-check” of the exposure predictions based on a comparison of predicted environmental concentrations (PECs) from a range of exposure models with measured environmental concentrations (MECs) from monitoring studies in various European countries, benchmarking the complexity of regulatory PEC models.

Initial results give no indication that complex models provide more accurate predictions of maximum MECs than simple models based on assumed key risk drivers, demonstrating that data-driven model refinement, grounded in real-world environmental monitoring and sensitivity analysis, can lead to more efficient and protective models.

Going into Year 4, PEC model analyses and model parameter sensitivity analyses will be continued; European MECs will be analyzed in more detail, considering e.g., national-level regulatory specificities and pesticide application. “Real” environmental concentrations (RECs) will be approximated and explored to optimize the comparison and assessment of protectiveness of PECs.

Policy relevance

The goal of of this project is to strengthen the scientific basis of ERA and to develop a clear risk profiling system for pesticides based on the investigation of available MECs in concert with the evaluation of PEC models and factors influencing their predictive capacity for the real exposure situation in the field (RECs). Contextualizing these exposure assessment-related aspects and assessing their transferability across different member states will provide insight into the state of realism and protectiveness and concrete improvement opportunities for chemical ERA.

P6.4.4.b_Y1_PPPEXPCS2_RPTU
Filter by
Address chemical pollution in the natural environment
Provide protection against most harmful chemicals
Shift away from animal testing
Biodiversity protection
Promoting the circular economy through safe materials
Studying persistent, mobile and toxic chemicals in soil, water and air across Europe
Bridging data gaps for some Alternaria toxins
Environmental burden of disease and health impact of chemicals
Hazard characterization and closing data gaps of emerging mycotoxins
Innovative approaches to soil contaminant assessment
Risk assessment of chemical mixtures measured in the human body
Tools, criteria, and methods used in risk assessment reviews
Improving the transfer and use of information on chemicals in products
Total human exposure to chemicals from multiple sources and settings
Closing data gaps in PBK modelling for endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs)
Effect-specific risk assessment reviews
Follow-up Immunotoxicity
Further development of an IATA for Metabolic Disruption
Improving computer models that simulate the behaviour of chemicals in the human body across different life stages
Integrated approaches to testing and assessment (IATA) for carcinogenicity
Making Adverse Outcome Pathways (AOPs) ready for use under EU Regulation
Potential of New Approach Methods to delineate between developmental and adult neurotoxicity hazard
TG+ Enniatin B1
Nanomaterials: applicability of New Approach Methodologies and assessment of baseline toxicity
Structured toxicological data and computer models to support next-generation chemical risk assessment
Studying the effects of pollutants on molting in arthropods
Studying the reliability of alternatives to fish toxicity testing of chemicals
Accumulation of microplastics and plastic additives in aquatic organisms and the potential of in vitro methods
Toxicity of water-soluble plastics: original form and changes due to environmental processes
Environment
Health effects
Human health
Monitoring methods
Risk assessment
NGRA
Mixtures
Human biomonitoring
Workers
Accumulation of microplastics and plastic additives in aquatic organisms and the potential of in vitro methods
Toxicity of water-soluble plastics: original form and changes due to environmental processes
Accumulation of microplastics and plastic additives in aquatic organisms and the potential of in vitro methods
Closing data gaps in PBK modelling for endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs)
Effect-specific risk assessment reviews
Follow-up Immunotoxicity
Further development of an IATA for Metabolic Disruption
Improving computer models that simulate the behaviour of chemicals in the human body across different life stages
Integrated approaches to testing and assessment (IATA) for carcinogenicity
Making Adverse Outcome Pathways (AOPs) ready for use under EU Regulation
Nanomaterials: applicability of New Approach Methodologies and assessment of baseline toxicity
Potential of New Approach Methods to delineate between developmental and adult neurotoxicity hazard
Structured toxicological data and computer models to support next-generation chemical risk assessment
Studying the effects of pollutants on molting in arthropods
Studying the reliability of alternatives to fish toxicity testing of chemicals
TG+ Enniatin B1
Toxicity of water-soluble plastics: original form and changes due to environmental processes
Bridging data gaps for some Alternaria toxins
Closing data gaps in PBK modelling for endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs)
Effect-specific risk assessment reviews
Environmental burden of disease and health impact of chemicals
Follow-up Immunotoxicity
Further development of an IATA for Metabolic Disruption
Hazard characterization and closing data gaps of emerging mycotoxins
Improving computer models that simulate the behaviour of chemicals in the human body across different life stages
Improving the transfer and use of information on chemicals in products
Innovative approaches to soil contaminant assessment
Integrated approaches to testing and assessment (IATA) for carcinogenicity
Making Adverse Outcome Pathways (AOPs) ready for use under EU Regulation
Potential of New Approach Methods to delineate between developmental and adult neurotoxicity hazard
Risk assessment of chemical mixtures measured in the human body
TG+ Enniatin B1
Tools, criteria, and methods used in risk assessment reviews
Total human exposure to chemicals from multiple sources and settings
Bridging data gaps for some Alternaria toxins
Environmental burden of disease and health impact of chemicals
Hazard characterization and closing data gaps of emerging mycotoxins
Innovative approaches to soil contaminant assessment
Risk assessment of chemical mixtures measured in the human body
Studying persistent, mobile and toxic chemicals in soil, water and air across Europe
Tools, criteria, and methods used in risk assessment reviews

Improving environmental risk assessments for plant protection products

Time span
-
Potential impacts
  • Supporting risk assessors at the EU and member state levels by providing improved tools for evaluating plant protection products during the authorisation process.
  • Enhancing the transition to a systems-based Environmental Risk Assessment process by improving the reusability of data generated during environmental risk assessments.
  • Streamline the Environmental Risk Assessment process for plant protection products by identifying opportunities to simplify assessments and allocate resources more efficiently.
RPTU (DE)
ANSES (FR)
SLU (SE)
EAWAG (CH)
EFSA (IT)
FOEN (CH)
KEMI (SE)
IEP-NRI (PL)
NIVA (NO)
UBA (DE)
UFZ (DE)
ULUND (SE)
UOB (GB)
UOS (DE)
Key messages
  • The scientific basis of the pesticide environmental risk assessment needs to be strengthened, and the regulatory complexity needs to be bechmarked;
  • The validation status of exposure models in the environmental risk assessment of pesticides needs to be improved;
  • Measured and predicted environmental pesticide concentrations have to be contextualized to assess the real exposure situation;
  • The overall aim is the optimization of complexity within the regulatory exposure assessment of pesticides to ensure protectiveness.
Overview

This project is part of PARC Activity “Risk assessment to support and promote efficient overall protection of biodiversity”, which focuses on enhancing environmental risk assessment (ERA) methods. The aim of this project is to investigate the potential for simplifying and improving the predictions in the exposure assessment of the authorization process for plant protection products (PPP, commonly known as pesticides) under Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009. The current process is intricate and resource-intensive, prompting to optimize the space between necessary model complexity to achieve a protective predictive capacity and regulatory feasibility. The focus is on the ERA of pesticides with the long-term aim to expand the scope to support chemical ERA in general.

During Y 1-3, this project performed an extensive “reality-check” of the exposure predictions based on a comparison of predicted environmental concentrations (PECs) from a range of exposure models with measured environmental concentrations (MECs) from monitoring studies in various European countries, benchmarking the complexity of regulatory PEC models.

Initial results give no indication that complex models provide more accurate predictions of maximum MECs than simple models based on assumed key risk drivers, demonstrating that data-driven model refinement, grounded in real-world environmental monitoring and sensitivity analysis, can lead to more efficient and protective models.

Going into Year 4, PEC model analyses and model parameter sensitivity analyses will be continued; European MECs will be analyzed in more detail, considering e.g., national-level regulatory specificities and pesticide application. “Real” environmental concentrations (RECs) will be approximated and explored to optimize the comparison and assessment of protectiveness of PECs.

Policy relevance

The goal of of this project is to strengthen the scientific basis of ERA and to develop a clear risk profiling system for pesticides based on the investigation of available MECs in concert with the evaluation of PEC models and factors influencing their predictive capacity for the real exposure situation in the field (RECs). Contextualizing these exposure assessment-related aspects and assessing their transferability across different member states will provide insight into the state of realism and protectiveness and concrete improvement opportunities for chemical ERA.

Contacts
Ralf Schulz (RPTU)
r.schulz [at] rptu.de
Larissa Herrmann (RPTU)
l.herrmann [at] rptu.de
Topics
Biodiversity protection
Keywords
Environment
NGRA
Risk assessment